← All recipes

sauces / basics / instant-pot

Thick yogurt in the Instant Pot (8 h plus straining)

Jump to ingredients ↓

Ingredients

  • 1 litre whole milk (fresh or UHT; skimmed gives a slack yogurt)
  • 50 g plain yogurt with live cultures, at room temperature — or a sachet of freeze-dried cultures
  • optional: 2 to 3 tbsp skimmed milk powder, for a firmer yogurt

Use the weight for the starter: the original note also said “about 2 tbsp”, but that measure does not match 50 g of yogurt.


The two levers, not to be confused

You want Lever Note
Thicker Straining through cloth It is the only one that removes liquid
More sour Hours of incubation (10-12 h) Past 10 h the gel contracts and weeps whey: more sour and more watery

Hence the choice: 8 to 9 hours, then strain.


Method

  1. Milk powder (if you use it): dissolve it in the cold milk, before heating. Afterwards it goes lumpy.

  2. Pasteurisation, about 30 min. Milk into the clean, dry inner pot. Yogurt, then press Adjust (or the button again) until boil appears. Lid resting on top. Stir once halfway through, the bottom catches.

Without a Yogurt button: Sauté on low with a thermometer, up to 82-85 °C, stirring.

For a firmer yogurt: when it beeps, hold the milk at 85 °C for 20 to 30 minutes with Sauté at minimum. That denatures the whey proteins and the gel comes out more compact. It is worth more than any extra hour of incubation.

  1. Cooling to 43-45 °C, 10-15 min. Take the inner pot out and stand it in a cold water bath. This is the critical step: above 50 °C the cultures die. Without a thermometer: a drop on your wrist, warm but not uncomfortable.

  2. Inoculation. Take out a cup of the warm milk, dissolve the 50 g of yogurt into it until smooth and lump-free, return it to the pot and stir gently.

  3. Incubation, 8 h. Pot in, lid on, Yogurt on normal (~43 °C), set 8:00. Do not open it and do not move the pot: a gel broken while it is forming never knits back together.

  4. Fridge, 6 h or overnight. Straight out of the machine it always looks too runny. That is normal; it sets as it chills.

  5. Straining, from cold. Cheesecloth, or a clean linen tea towel with no smell of detergent, in a sieve over a bowl, in the fridge.

Time Result
2 h Breakfast Greek style
4 h Thick, stands on the spoon ← the default
8-12 h Nearly labneh, spreadable

Strain it cold, never straight off the heat: at 43 °C the gel is fragile and goes through the cloth.


Afterwards

Yield at 4 h of straining: about 600 g yogurt, about 400 ml whey.

The starter: keep 50 g back for next time, before straining. It holds for 5 or 6 cycles, then the cultures weaken (slack yogurt, odd acidity) and you start again from a new pot.

The whey: this is acid whey, you cannot make ricotta from it, the proteins stayed in the yogurt. Better uses:

  • Bread and focaccia, in place of the water
  • Pancakes and waffles, with bicarbonate of soda instead of baking powder, half a teaspoon per 250 ml
  • Marinade for chicken, 3 to 4 hours
  • Soaking oats, smoothies, a starter for lacto-fermenting vegetables
  • Not for dried pulses: the acid toughens the skins
  • Keeps 2 to 3 weeks in the fridge, getting steadily more sour, or frozen in cubes

If something goes wrong

Still liquid milk — dead cultures: the milk was too hot when inoculated (step 3), or the starter was past it.

Grainy, not smooth — incubated too long or too warm; or the starter was lumpy at step 4.

Whey on the surface before straining — incubation too long. Come down to 7 or 8 hours.

Tastes of nothing — 8 hours is not enough for that milk: try 9 or 10 next time.